Gourmet Italian Supermarket in Middletown, NJ

Address

1151 Route 35, Middletown, NJ 07748

Get Directions

Contact

Phone: (732) 275-1144

Store Hours

Open Monday to Sunday, 7am-8pm

View Holiday Hours

Livoti’s in Middletown

At Livoti’s Old World Market, we believe in treating our customers like family. We deliver on our promise of quality, consistency, and freshness by offering the best tasting meals and Italian grocery items right here in Middletown, NJ. There’s a reason why our customers have voted us Monmouth County’s #1 gourmet caterer, and you’ll see for yourself when you visit our gourmet bakery, delicatessen, butcher shop, floral department, and more. You can find us at 1151 Route 35 in Middletown, NJ or visit our other locations in Marlboro, Freehold, Aberdeen, and Brick. Stop in and say hello today - we can’t wait to serve you!

What You’ll Find at Our Middletown Location

If you’re looking for Italian specialty products ranging from canned items and desserts to imported cheeses and meats, you can count on Livoti’s, your neighborhood Italian marketplace in Middletown. Right here in the heart of town, you’ll find the freshest ingredients and beloved Italian goods, delicious prepared foods, and so much more.

Gourmet Butcher in Middletown, NJ

At Livoti’s, our professional butchers are happy to serve our customers and can guarantee nothing but quality ingredients and reputable sourcing from the top manufacturers when it comes to our products. Our poultry is all natural with no antibiotics, and we provide a high quality line of pork and beef from Chairman’s Reserve. Best of all, we offer our own line of chicken, pork, and lamb sausages, along with premade meats, prepared in house all 7 days of the week. Visit our butcher department in Middletown today!

Fresh Seafood Department

Our seafood department in Middletown is the perfect place to pick up something delicious for dinner. You’ll meet the family behind Catch of the Day, who have most likely met the people who caught or raised the fish you’re about to bring home. Stop in and shop our wide selection of locally-sourced, high quality seafood that the whole family will love.

Gourmet Italian Deli in Middletown, NJ

Authentic meal prepping and delicious food is our specialty at Livoti’s gourmet Italian deli in Middletown, NJ. Come pick up flavorful cold cuts from the popular Boar’s Head line or try our custom starters, sides, or main courses for any family meal or company party. Whatever you’re in the mood for, we’ve got you covered.

Olive Bar

From delicious cheeses and savory meats to pickled veggies and sweet dressings, our refined olive bar at our Middletown location is sure to impress your tastebuds! Build a nutritious, colorful salad or a succulent antipasto dish with our delicious display!

Gourmet Cheese Shop

We know that you probably have a lot on your shopping list, but you’ve got to check out our Gourmet Cheese Shop next time you’re at Livoti’s. We make our fresh mozzarella in-house and offer over 100 types of cheese from all around the world. You’ll be sure to find old and new favorites while you’re here!

Gourmet Italian Bakery in Middletown

Taste Europe’s finest selection of sweets when you stop by our gourmet Italian bakery in Middletown, NJ. Whether you’re craving our soft macaroons, our creamy cupcakes, or just need a stunning cookie platter to wow your guests at your next gathering, you will be amazed by all of our bakery counter options at Livoti’s. Our bakery also brews Italian-style coffee to boost your mood and your energy all day long.

Fresh Bread in Middletown, NJ

Find your new favorite bread at Livoti’s in Middletown. Shop our artisan breads, classic loaves, semolinas, bastones, and so much more. No matter what you choose, you can’t go wrong when it comes to bread! There’s something for everyone in the family at Livoti’s.

Pizza Station

Calling all pizza lovers in Middletown and northern Monmouth County! Get ready to try our hot and sizzling, cheesy pizzas baked hot in the center of our toasty brick ovens. With a large selection of different toppings to choose from, the whole family will be impressed with our creative recipes and your kids will be begging you for more. Order a Livoti’s pie for pickup or delivery today! Feeling hungry while you shop? Our Middletown store features a pizza bar - so you can grab a seat and enjoy your slice right here with us.

Peanut Butter Grinding Station in NJ

Want to step up your game when it comes to making your own food? Start right here at Livoti’s when you try our one-of-a-kind peanut butter grinding station right here in Middletown! It’s never been this easy and fun to grab freshly-ground, all-natural peanut butter, honey-roasted peanut butter, and almond butter and bring it right home to your family. Come try it out today!

Italian Grocery & Specialties in NJ

Italy is known for its love of good company and exquisite foods. Food is something that truly brings people together, especially when it comes to family. At Livoti’s, we make that even more possible with our impressive selection of Italian specialties, quality produce, preserved goods, beloved desserts, tasty snacks, and more! We even carry the popular national brand items you already know and love!

Floral Department in Middletown, NJ

There’s nothing like receiving fresh flowers after a hard day or to remind you that you’re loved. Here at Livoti’s, our floral department in Middletown gives our customers easy access to beautiful bouquets. Whether you are looking for something simple or elaborate, we have you covered, and will be happy to help you pick an arrangement that feels perfect for your special occasion.

Italian Catering in Middletown, NJ

From our specialty pastas and sub sandwiches to our signature meat dishes and seafood platters, Livoti’s has created and maintained a phenomenal reputation as Monmouth County’s most beloved and trusted gourmet caterer. We offer a mixed array of hot and cold dishes big enough to feed a crowd, a piping hot buffet selection guaranteed to impress, and much more at our Middletown location. We are confident in delivering spectacular catering services for your special event no matter the season or occasion. Order online, in person, or by phone and we’ll be happy to serve you!

Order from Middletown Location

Order Groceries

Livoti’s makes online orders and deliveries easy via Instacart. Don’t worry about not being able to shop for your family if you’re feeling under the weather or just don’t have the time. Order today and your favorite Italian groceries will be delivered right to your doorstep.

Order from Instacart

Shop Livoti’s Old World Market in NJ

Customers know as soon as they walk through our doors that Livoti’s is truly something special. Maybe it’s our way of delivering top of the line customer service, promoting fresh and exceptional quality foods, or doing it all with a genuine smile on our faces, making our customers feel like family. Whatever it is, we’ll keep doing it for years to come, because our customers deserve the best of the best. We are proud to serve Italy’s most authentic and beloved food products, bringing the country’s special love for family, community, and cuisine directly to New Jersey residents. Visit us in Middletown, NJ or come to our other locations in Monmouth and Ocean County. We’re excited to see you at Livoti’s Old World Market!